HSIE Teachers
  • Home
  • Blog
  • 11 Geography
    • Earth's Natural Systems >
      • Key Terms
      • Processes, cycles and circulations >
        • Atmospheric systems
        • Hydrological systems >
          • Georges River Introduction
          • Georges River
          • Georges River Fieldwork
          • Water Management
          • Flow of Water Though Catchments
          • Catchments - Key Terms
          • Murray-Darling Catchment
          • Human impacts on hydrological processes
        • Geomorphic systems
        • Ecological systems
    • People, Patterns and Processes >
      • Population and resource consumption >
        • Demographic processes
        • Demographic processes - Mortality
        • Population pyramids
        • Challenges of changing population
    • Human-Environment Interactions >
      • A contemporary hazard >
        • Volcanic Eruptions
        • Floods 2022
        • COVID-19
        • Bushfire 2019-2020 >
          • Spatial distribution
          • Managing a contemporary hazard
  • 12 Geography (from 2025)
    • Global Sustainability >
      • Pillars of Sustainability
      • Evaluating Sustainability
      • Tourism - Nature and Spatial Patterns
      • Tourism - Influences >
        • Biophsical Influences
        • Ecological Influences
        • Economic Influences
        • Socio-Cultural Influences
        • Political Influences
        • Organisational Influences
        • Technological Influences
      • Tourism - Trends and Future Directions
      • Tourism - Sustainability >
        • Impacts of Tourism
        • Tourism in Venice
    • Urban and Rural Places >
      • One urban place - Ashbury (suburb) >
        • Ashbury - location and character
        • Ashbury - changes
        • Ashbury - responses to changes
    • Ecosystems and Global Biodiversity >
      • Coral Triangle
  • Geographical Tools
    • Tools Checklist
    • Maps >
      • Topo map basics
      • Area and Grid Reference
      • Sight Lines
      • Bearing
      • Gradient
      • Cross Section
      • Vertical Exaggeration
      • Sketch Maps
      • Synoptic Charts
      • Latitude and Longitude
    • Geographical Inquiry >
      • Soil characteristics
      • Vegetation Profile
      • Fieldsketch
      • Water Quality
      • Microclimate Fieldwork
    • Graphs and Statistics

HSIETeachers.com

Ideas, resources, inspiration

Tourism - Are we loving Venice to death? Part 2

6/30/2021

0 Comments

 
A previous post written in 2014 described the impact that tourism was having on Venice. You can read this post here:
Tourism - Are we loving Venice to death? Part 1

The COVID-19 pandemic, and it's impact on global tourism since that post has resulted in a new range of impacts and an opportunity for reassessing the nature of tourism on the island.

The pandemic has resulted in months of empty shops, restaurants and hotels. As Venice begins to open with some slight changes (more takeaways, outdoor dining, etc) a broader review of tourism on the island must be considered. The over tourism being experienced prior to the pandemic was pushing residents out due to rising house prices, grocery stores were being replaced with souvenir shops and accommodation was being replaced with Airbnbs. Large cruise ships were bringing in tourists who were only on Venice for day trips resulting in them rushing around to the see the main sights, congregating in concentrated areas, and economic benefits not being shared by the wider community.

The pandemic has provided an opportunity for residents to reclaim the city, to try to make tourism more sustainable and diverse. Some of the suggestions being considered are limited access to attractions by introducing quotas and booking, and more regulation of tourist flows.

Further reading:

Life Returns to Venice as Italy's COVID restrictions ease.

Venice Tourism May Never be the Same. It Could be Better.

"Kill Venice": a systems thinking conceptualisation of urban life, economy and resilience in tourist cities.

0 Comments

Tourism - Are we loving Venice to death?

6/18/2014

1 Comment

 
The continual movement of cruise ship passengers in and out of Venice presents a conundrum in terms of tourist carrying capacity and sustainability. Over 60,000 visitors enter Venice each day, many from large cruise ships docking in Venice's port. The huge number of tourists coming into Venice provide a continual market for tours, gondola rides, water taxis, ferries, masks, venetian glass trinkets and jewellery and endless assortments of plastic souvenirs. Cafés and restaurants line the streets and canals targeting tourists with meal deals and views of iconic streetscapes or panoramic views of the historic canals. The Rialto Bridge is constantly packed with people after the perfect view, portrait or selfie shot. Surrounding the bridge the cafés and hotels nearby are flooded with tourists doing the traditional tourist trail around the islands. 

The benefits of large scale tourism in Venice seem obvious - taxes, jobs (both direct and indirect), funds to support other aspects of the community. However given that many of those who travel on large cruise ships sleep and often eat on board, the benefits may not be as clear as one might expect. Despite the huge numbers of people coming into Venice they spend little per person compared to those who visit, stay in a local hotel and consume all their meals at local restaurants and cafés. 

Preservation
If managed correctly, funds received from the large numbers of tourists can be used to fund much needed restoration projects. Tourists pay a city tax when they stay in a hotel in Italy. In Venice this money is said to go towards conservation and restoration of historic buildings and monuments. However, a large proportion of money collected is used on administrative positions and policing, as well as marketing campaigns to encourage more tourists. Restoration and conservation initiatives exist but their funding comes from elsewhere. 
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Tourism has provided motivation and a source of income for preserving the gondola as a mode of transport. Traditionally a form of public transport, the gondola evolved until the mid 20th century. The profession of being a gondolier is strictly controlled by a guild and the vast majority of the actual gondolas are owned by one business. The gondola industry provides jobs not only for the gondoliers but also those working at Tramontin boatyard involved in repair and upkeep.


Homogenised culture
A main reason that people travel is to experience another culture. Given the global nature of the cities that many of us live in, we can already taste foods, purchase groceries, listen to music from foreign cultures in our own cities. Many who travel want to have an authentic experience of what life is like in another culture. However, the real Venetians are leaving the city in droves. Many leave in search of a professional life outside of the tourist industry. Abandoned flats are purchased by hoteliers and converted into guesthouses. The impact of the hotel industry has pushed up housing prices making housing affordability for locals a serious issue. Local stores have closed down leaving few options for local residents to buy groceries or necessities. Shop closures mark the creation of new tourist and designer clothing stores. The real Venice is dying. 


The vast number of tourists reduces the ability of cafés and restaurants to provide authentic dining experiences. In some of the cafés in Venice packaged or frozen food is served to enable the cafés to cater for the vast number of people in peak periods. As a result travellers may be disappointed by this aspect of their stay as they are not experiencing the authentic taste of Venice. 


Mass production of tourist items reduces the ability to see or purchase authentic and original  works. The Murano glass industry (or Venetian glass)  is known worldwide. Tourists can visit Murano glass factories and stores, but unless they get off the beaten track most tourists will only be exposed to fairly simplified designs and reproductions available in the main tourist areas. While some traditional Venetian mask and costume stores still exist, it is more common to see stores filled with plastic replicas made in China. 
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Local protest
The huge numbers of tourists coming into Venice is seen as a curse by some of the locals. Various graffiti sites show slogans such as, "No big ships" and "No big ship, no stupid tourists". Handmade signage in various parts of the area indicate the continual intrusion of large numbers of tourists in the everyday life of locals. No Big Ships Venice Committee is a local protest group attempting to limit the size of ships entering Venice. In January a ban was out in place to limit the number of cruise ships entering Giudecca Canal, but the ban was lifted a few months later after lobbying from workers on the port.


Environmental impacts and structural damage
The huge cruise liners visiting Venice create huge water currents which erode the water ways and damage the city's fragile foundations.Venice, a sinking city, suffers from flooding regularly and it is believed that the extra erosion caused by the cruise ships is worsening the effects of flooding and damaging the lagoon ecosystem, itself a natural flood mitigator.
For more resources to support 12 Geography - People and Economic Activity (Tourism), see the Economic Activity site.

Edit: An update for this topic has been posted in a new post Tourism - Are we loving Venice to death? Part 2.
1 Comment
    12 Geography
    11 Geography
    Geography Skills
    Legal Studies
    Studies of Religion
    Commerce
    History
    Changing Places
    Environmental Change

    Categories

    All
    10 Geography
    11 Geo
    11 Geography
    12 Geography
    12 Legal Studies
    6 Geography
    7 Geography
    8 Geography
    9 Geography
    Aboriginal Culture
    Aboriginal Education
    Accreditation
    Adani
    Affordability
    AGTA2017
    AGTA 2022
    AGTA 2024
    AI
    Ancient History
    ANZAC
    App
    Arctic
    Ashbury
    Asia
    Augmented Reality
    Australian Curriculum
    Australians At War
    Balmain Foreshore Project
    Biomes
    Biophysical Interactions
    Biosphere
    Both Ways
    Buddhism
    Bush Care
    Bushfires
    Business Studies
    BYOD
    Cabramatta
    Case Studies
    Catchment
    Catchment Functioning
    Change
    Changing Places
    ChatGPT
    Citizenship
    Climate Change
    Coastal Geography
    Cold War
    Collaboration
    Commerce
    Consumer Choice
    Contemporary Hazard
    Coral Reefs
    Cross Curriculum Priorities
    Cross Curriculum Project
    Cultural Integration
    Curriculum Reform
    Deputy Principal
    Differentiation
    Discrimination
    Economic Activity
    Ecosystem Restoration
    Ecosystems At Risk
    Elearning
    Elective Geography
    Environmental Change
    Excursion
    Faculty
    Fertility
    Fieldwork
    Fluvial
    Forest
    Gaming
    General Capabilities
    Geographical Investigation
    Geography
    Geomorphic Hazards
    Georges River
    Global
    Google
    Great Barrier Reef
    GTAConference2024
    GTANSW2017
    GTA NSW Conference 2018
    Herculanuem
    Historiography
    History
    Homelessness
    Housing
    HSC
    Human Environment Interactions
    Human Rights
    India
    Insurance
    Kakadu
    Leadership
    Learning Across The Curriculum
    Learning And Support
    Legal Studies
    Legal Studies Association
    Life Skills
    Light Rail
    Literacy
    Liveability
    Management
    Mekong
    Metroline
    Mining
    Modern History
    Modifications
    Natural Hazards
    Natural Resources
    Natural Systems
    New Nsw Syllabus
    New Syllabus
    Online Learning
    Outcomes
    Papua New Guinea
    PBL
    Personal Finance
    Picture Books
    Place And Liveability
    Population
    Population Pyramids
    Precis
    Preliminary
    Primary
    Principal
    Problem Based Learning
    Professional Associations
    Professional Learning
    Program
    Project Based Learning
    Purpose
    Refugees
    Reporting
    Revision
    Rivers
    Rock Art
    Sea Level Rise
    Senior Geography Project
    SGP
    Shelter
    Sia
    Skills
    Social Media
    Solutions
    Stage 3
    Stage 4
    Stage 5
    Stage 6
    Studies Of Religion
    Sustainability
    Sydenham To Bankstown
    Sydney
    Teacher Visioning
    Teacher Wellbeing
    Tech
    Technology
    Tourism
    Transport
    Travel
    Urbanisation
    Urban Places
    Venice
    Video
    Virtual Reality
    Visible Leadership
    Vision
    Volcanoes
    WestConnex
    World
    World Cities
    World Heritage Sites
    Writing
    WWI
    WWII
    Year 10
    Year 9

    Archives

    December 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    December 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    June 2021
    March 2021
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • 11 Geography
    • Earth's Natural Systems >
      • Key Terms
      • Processes, cycles and circulations >
        • Atmospheric systems
        • Hydrological systems >
          • Georges River Introduction
          • Georges River
          • Georges River Fieldwork
          • Water Management
          • Flow of Water Though Catchments
          • Catchments - Key Terms
          • Murray-Darling Catchment
          • Human impacts on hydrological processes
        • Geomorphic systems
        • Ecological systems
    • People, Patterns and Processes >
      • Population and resource consumption >
        • Demographic processes
        • Demographic processes - Mortality
        • Population pyramids
        • Challenges of changing population
    • Human-Environment Interactions >
      • A contemporary hazard >
        • Volcanic Eruptions
        • Floods 2022
        • COVID-19
        • Bushfire 2019-2020 >
          • Spatial distribution
          • Managing a contemporary hazard
  • 12 Geography (from 2025)
    • Global Sustainability >
      • Pillars of Sustainability
      • Evaluating Sustainability
      • Tourism - Nature and Spatial Patterns
      • Tourism - Influences >
        • Biophsical Influences
        • Ecological Influences
        • Economic Influences
        • Socio-Cultural Influences
        • Political Influences
        • Organisational Influences
        • Technological Influences
      • Tourism - Trends and Future Directions
      • Tourism - Sustainability >
        • Impacts of Tourism
        • Tourism in Venice
    • Urban and Rural Places >
      • One urban place - Ashbury (suburb) >
        • Ashbury - location and character
        • Ashbury - changes
        • Ashbury - responses to changes
    • Ecosystems and Global Biodiversity >
      • Coral Triangle
  • Geographical Tools
    • Tools Checklist
    • Maps >
      • Topo map basics
      • Area and Grid Reference
      • Sight Lines
      • Bearing
      • Gradient
      • Cross Section
      • Vertical Exaggeration
      • Sketch Maps
      • Synoptic Charts
      • Latitude and Longitude
    • Geographical Inquiry >
      • Soil characteristics
      • Vegetation Profile
      • Fieldsketch
      • Water Quality
      • Microclimate Fieldwork
    • Graphs and Statistics