HSIE Teachers
  • Home

Ideas, resources, inspiration

Feedback on the new Modern History draft syllabus

8/11/2016

0 Comments

 

Guest blogger: Bruce Barclay

​The recently released stage six draft modern history syllabus fails to clearly articulate a vision for the study of modern history in a globalised world. In its previous incarnation, the stage six syllabus at least paid lip service to areas of modern history which were not European in nature, i.e. India as one option. This final draft does not reflect the four options which were tabled to teachers who took the time to provide feedback to BOSTES previously. Teachers of this subject have been ignored with the release of the final draft.

The National Study and Peace and Conflict topic areas have been left relatively unscathed. However the inclusion of Iran into the national study topic area replaces India which is a lost opportunity. Similarly, the Peace and Conflict topic retains the main options, with the inclusion of Conflict in the Gulf 1991-2011, which replaces the UN as Peacekeeper. Essentially these two areas of study have escaped political influence.

One of the real, if not the most problematic areas, is the core topic. Instead of utilising one of the options tabled at the consultation process, BOSTES has obviously bowed to political pressure and ignored the recommendations of the majority of teachers. World War One was a topic which although staid, at least had the advantage of being politically neutral and allowed teachers to engage in different national studies with no disadvantage to its students. For example a teacher of the USSR topic can build on students’ knowledge of the World War One topic. However as it stands, the core topic is Nazi Germany 1933-39 and teachers have to cover 9 detailed dot points taking up 60% of course time. To further compound the problem, teachers then need to teach another dictator, e.g. Pol Pot for 30% of the course. This begs the question: why is Nazi Germany deemed the most important topic for the core? Compounding the obvious bias, is that instead of removing Nazi Germany from the National Study it keeps Nazi Germany, but focuses on 1914-33. Clearly any teacher with half a brain will teach the German National Study first, then the Core/Nazi topic and if you haven’t got your fix of Nazi German history, you could finish with the European Conflict option for the Peace and Conflict topic. Already roughly 70% of the state teaches the Nazi option for the National Study so BOSTES wants the rest of the state to follow suit. As one person at the BOSTES consultation meeting at Hurstville remarked “That’s the end of the Soviet Union in every sense”. The USSR and for that matter the other options have been "relegated to the dustbin of history," to quote Goebbels, I mean Trotsky. It’s already working!

Unlike the Ancient History course, BOSTES have removed the Personality topic from Modern History and replaced it with Change in The Modern World. I actually thought there has been a lot of change in the modern world in the twentieth century - that is why students love studying Modern History. BOSTES wants teachers to not only teach a personality, e.g. Gorbachev but link it to a time frame of nearly 70 years - The Changing World Order 1945-2011. This option has 19 dot points to cover, plus an evaluation of Gorbachev during the Cold War period. Furthermore, as a hat tip to the old UN as Peacekeeper topic, teachers have to assess the role and impact of the UN as international peacekeeper in relation to one trouble spot in the world, e.g. Somalia. Evidently the old inconsistencies of comparability between the ancient and modern course remain but are amplified, further alienating modern history teachers. If I was a student and had equal interest in modern and ancient history I would choose ancient for ease of content and variety.

I hope that someone more technically adept than myself will be able to create a parody of the modern syllabus using snippets from The Downfall movie on youtube. I won’t even start on the exam specifications.
0 Comments
    Picture

    Louise Swanson

    Deputy Principal at a Sydney high school. Coordinating author of the new Geoactive book series.

    Follow @LouiseSwanson
    12 Geography
    11 Geography
    Geography Skills
    Changing Places
    Environmental Change
    Landscapes & Landforms
    Place & Liveability
    Water In The World

    Archives

    January 2020
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

    Categories

    All
    10 Geography
    11 Geo
    11 Geography
    12 Geography
    12 Legal Studies
    6 Geography
    7 Geography
    8 Geography
    9 Geography
    Accreditation
    Adani
    Adoption
    Affordability
    AGTA2017
    Ancient History
    Arctic
    Asia
    Asia And Australia's Engagement With Asia
    Australian Curriculum
    Biophysical Interactions
    Buddhism
    Bushfires
    Business
    Business Studies
    BYOD
    Case Studies
    Changing Places
    Children
    Climate Change
    Cold War
    Commerce
    Consumer Choice
    Contemporary Issues
    Coral Reefs
    Cross Curriculum Priorities
    Discrimination
    Domestic Violence
    Economic Activity
    Ecosystems At Risk
    E-learning
    Environmental Change
    Family Law
    Fertility
    Fieldwork
    Gaming
    General Capabilities
    Geography
    Global
    Google
    Great Barrier Reef
    GTANSW2017
    GTA NSW Conference 2018
    Historiography
    History
    Homelessness
    Housing
    HSC
    Human Rights
    India
    Insurance
    Learning Across The Curriculum
    Learning And Support
    Legal Studies
    Legal Studies Association
    Life Skills
    Light Rail
    Literacy
    Liveability
    Management
    Mekong
    Metroline
    Mining
    Modern History
    Modifications
    Natural Hazards
    Natural Resources
    New Nsw Syllabus
    Outcomes
    Personal Finance
    Place And Liveability
    Population
    Population Pyramids
    Preliminary
    Primary
    Professional Associations
    Professional Learning
    Program
    Project Based Learning
    Refugees
    Reporting
    Revision
    Same-sex
    Senior Geography Project
    Separation
    SGP
    Shelter
    Social Media
    Solutions
    Stage 3
    Stage 4
    Stage 5
    Stage 6
    Studies Of Religion
    Surrogacy And Birth Teachnologies
    Sustainability
    Sydenham To Bankstown
    Sydney
    Tech
    Technol
    Technology
    Tourism
    Transport
    Travel
    Urbanisation
    Urban Places
    Virtual Reality
    WestConnex
    World
    World Cities
    World Heritage Sites
    Writing
    Young Offenders

    Tweets by LouiseSwanson
L. Swanson
  • Home