The cartoons below have been embedded from the Sydney Morning Herald and the Daily Telegraph.
Cartoons are a form of visual representation of ideas, views and concepts. It is important that students develop skills in interpreting cartoons. Interpreting cartoons involves knowledge of the context of the cartoon, identifying different issues being explored in the cartoon, identifying the techniques used by the artist, and considering the views or opinions that the artist is trying to convey.
- What is the cartoon about?
- Who is represented in the cartoon? Why?
Knowledge of the context:
- What events have happened?
- Look at the date of the cartoon. What events had happened at the time the cartoon had been drawn?
- Who are the key people/roles involved in the event/issue?
Identifying issues explored:
- What can you see in the cartoon? What words are used?
- What concepts are being explored?
- Has the artist used symbolism, irony, analogy or exaggeration in communicating?
- Is the cartoon persuasive?
Views and opinions:
- Can you identify the political views or perspective of the artist?
- How are these views or perspective communicated?
- What other opinions are there about this issue?
Tourists could fly to the island by helicopter or travel by boat, and were then required to wear a hard hat and gas mask to do the tour of the site on foot. The annual revenue generated by White Island Tours for the local Maori tribe, Ngati Awa was $NZ4.5 million.The nearby town of Whakatane in the Bay of Plenty is the gateway to Whakaari and is a town of approximately 34,000. During holiday season, the town becomes packed with caravans, and the motels, hotel, restaurants are full of tourists. Tourism is the lifeblood of the town.
Geomorphic processes that caused the disaster
New Zealand is particularly tectonically active, and earthquakes and volcanoes are common. Whaakari/White Island is a typical open vent volcanic system with magma not too far below the surface. The volcano is extremely volatile. It has a crater system enclosed within the crater, it has a superheated crater lake, there are noxious gases escaping from the gas vents, and there have been previous explosive eruptions. The eruption that occurred is known as an hydrothermal eruption, with the volcano spewing gas at temperatures at a minimum of 200 degrees celcius.
Responses to the disaster
Immediately following the disaster, the local tribes imposed a rahui, a cultural ban, on the waters along the coast following the explosion. In addition, a maritime exclusion zone of 5km around the island was imposed following the event, to provide exclusive access to police and the defence force. Tour boats were quarantined. A no-fly zone was also ordered after the eruption. Police and the Defence Force, including six bomb disposal specialists were involved in rescue and recovery operations.
The island was heavily toxic following the eruption. Initial visits were very short, with teams using breathing equipment to allow them to search for up to 75 minutes at a time. They needed to wear three protective layers and wade through dense acidic mud. Recovery divers had to be washed clean following recovery dives due to the acidity of the water.
Management strategies to reduce impacts of similar hazard events in the future
Tours which allow walking around the volcanic island no longer run. There are some scenic flights which allow a view of the island from a distance.
GNS Science undertake research on natural Earth system processes and resources, and are New Zealand’s geological hazards information authority. GNS Science and the Earthquake Commission work together to provide information through the GeoNet website. It monitors volcanic activity using seismometers, acoustic sensors and webcams. Samples are also collected from the island frequently. This ongoing monitoring and assessment provides the public with information about the changing risk level for the volcano. GeoNet uses Volcano Alert Bulletins to asses the rick of the volcano.
The Bay of Plenty Civil Defence Emergency Management group has overall responsibility for managing hazards and risks associated with Whakaari/White Island. They have developed a Whakaari/White Island Response Plan. This was developed in December 2019, and specified the roles and responsibility of different groups and agencies in the event of a similar disaster.
Tour operators are required to regularly communicate with each other to share knowledge of observations on the island, they need to directly communicate with GNS, and need to carry out their own individual risk assessment on each landing on the island. Information about the risks associated with walking around and active volcano is communicated to any visitors to the site.
1. Describe the location of Whakaari/White Island.
2. Describe how White Island was used by people.
3. Outline the impacts of the White Island disaster.
4. Examine figure 1. Explain the geomorphic processes that caused the disaster on White Island.
5. Explain the difficulties in the rescue and recovery mission on White Island following the eruption.
6. Propose the key points to be considered in developing a risk management plan for use of White Island in the future.
Spatial dimensions - Location and extent
A timeline of the ring of fire around NSW, Victoria and the ACT.
Aerial footage shows bushfires raging in the Australian state of Victoria
"Uncharted territory": Berejiklian says fire crisis in unprecedented.
Two fires have been upgraded to an emergency level as the state looks at a horror afternoon.
When bushfires make their own weather.
Intense "firestorms" forming from Australia's deadly wildfires.
Supercell bushfire thunderstorms, tornadoes, fire-whirls and other deadly fires that spin.
The bushfires in Australia are so big they're generating their own weather - "pyrocumulonimbus" thunderstorms that can start more fires.
BBC on Australian bushfires
Weirs continued to flow through drought and fires
This is not normal: Explaining Bushfires and Climate Change
Bushfire survival supersedes Christmas plans as firefighters battle infernos
How to monitor the bushfires raging across Australia.
Full List of Fire and Emergency Chiefs' recommendations to the Federal Government.
A load of rubbish: Greg Mullins says he wants a more proactive approach to fires and climate change
Prescribed burning: what is it and will more reduce bushfire risks?
Bushfires and Climate Change
This is not normal: Explaining Bushfires and Climate Change
Explainer: What are the underlying causes of Australia's shocking bushfire season
Bureau of Meteorology chart shows how temperatures have soared in Australia in the past century
Australian wildfires threaten Sydney water supplies.
Sydney temperatures pass 41C as firefighters injured, homes destroyed, state of emergency declared.
Nations counts cost of Australian blazes after community devastated.
Depression and suicide linked to air pollution in new global air study.
Bushfire death toll rises as fires sweep across South Australia and NSW
Saving Balmoral: on the bushfire battle lines as a town is threatened with extinction.
"This is hurting" Heartache and hardworking inside RFS headquarters.
Western Australia bushfires devastate the Stirling Ranges - one of the world's richest biodiversity hotspots.
SA hard hit as Australian fires burn into the night - as it happened.
Sydney smoke three times worse this NSW bushfire seasons, but health effects from "medium-term" exposure unclear.
We are seeing the very worst of our scientific predictions come to pass in these bushfire.
Fire damage shuts Blue Mountains line to electric trains for months.
Health impacts of bushfires won't be known for years, experts say.
For First Nations people the bushfires bring a particular grief, burning what makes us who we are.
"Australia's first climate change refugees"
Massive queues as people flee NSW towns ahead of worsening bushfire threat.
Bushfire ravages main strata of NSW town Cobargo
Darkness at noon: Australia's bushfire of terror
Thousands swarm to Australian beaches to escape bushfire
Australian bushfires from the air: before and after images show scale of devastation.
NSW fires: Financial shock looms for those looking to rebuild, RFS boss warns.
Cut off: How the Mallacoota fire unfolded.
Impacts on wildlife
"Silent death": Australia's bushfires push countless species to extinction.
Animals have an astounding response to bushfire.
Koala's are the face of Australian tourism: What now after the fires?
Carers pushed to breaking point: Cash needed to rebuild animal populations, Greens say.
As fires rage across Australia, fears grow for rare species.
South Australia's iconic Kangaroo Island could see rare species wiped out after devastating bushfires.
"Starvation event" shows wildlife may need human help to survive.
Australia fires: humanitarian group describes "apocalyptic scenes of wildlife devastation on Kangaroo Island
Koalas could be listed as endangered in parts of the country after taking an "extraordinary hit"
"Assassin" spiders feared extinct after Kangaroo Island bushfires
Impacts on water
Australia's bushfires will create big problem for fresh drinking water
Impacts on tourism
Tourism loses $4.5b to bushfires as overseas visitors cancel
New Zealand's glaciers are turning red and it's because of Australia's bushfires.
New Zealand glaciers turn brown from Australian bushfires' smoke, ash and dust.
"Call for help": International response to Australian fires.
"Apocalyptic": New Zealand shrouded ins make from Australian bushfires
"Exhaustion point": Worst to come for NSW bushfires.
Defending the "un-defendable": How Batlow was saved.
Four Ways GIS Improves Rapid Response to Natural Disasters.
Firefighters battle to save NSW and Victorian coastal towns - in pictures
Balmoral RFS captain says Rural Fire Service "abandoned" village as bushfire bore down.
Indigenous groups, strategies and responses
Meet the all-female Indigenous fire crews protecting community, family and sacred land
Cultural Burning is about more than just hazard reduction.
Yuin Indigenous Australians unite in historic healing ceremony at Mount Guluga
Indigenous knowledge combines with Western science to look after country
Australian fires: Aboriginal planners say the bush "needs to burn"
First all-indigenous NSW firefighting crews protecting sacred sites, remote communities
Government responses to fires
Airlift from fire-ravaged Mallacoota under way.
Morrison's government on bushfires: from attacking climate "lunatics" to calling in the troops.
PM calls up reservists for firefighting effort.
Government rejected major air tanker expansion
Victoria calls in the Army to bury "tens of thousands" of dead livestock.
Major increase in Defence bushfire-fighting support.
"Ecological tragedy": $50m in federal cash to aid wildlife after fires
PM to announce bushfire support package for small business
Grants and low-interest loans announced for small businesses hit with major asset or revenue loss from bushfires
NGOs and community responses
Sikh group giving free hot meals to victims hailed as "legends".
Leading scientists condemn political inaction on climate change as Australia "literally burns".
Australia's fires have pumped out more emissions than 100 nations combined
Effectiveness of responses
NSW needs a royal commission into bushfires
Greg Mullins, former NSW Fire Commissioner talks tough on bushfire response.
Should fossil fuels pay for Australia's new bushfire reality? It is the industry most responsible.
Federal cabinet meets to discuss long-term response to bushfires.
Firies "ignored" on climate by government.
The government response to the bushfire crisis has been evasive, tepid, tone-deaf and above all too late.
The Morrison Government's failure to act on predicted disaster is damning
Bushfire experts say it's time to revisit Black Saturday recommendations and stop people building in highly dangerous areas.
Bushfire-destroyed homes should not be rebuilt in riskiest area, experts say
Mental health support boosted for bushfire victims
Victoria – Joint Task Force 646
Following a request from Victorian Premier, Daniel Andrews, on December 31, naval vessels, helicopter and fixed wing military aircraft were made ready for use in evacuations. This was decided in consultation with the Prime Minister and Defence Chief General Angus Campbell.
HMAS Choules transported approximately 1100 evacuees from Mallacoota to Western Port on January 4-5. The ship then returned to Mallacoota to deliver diesel fuel and a fuel management team to keep generators running. RAAF Black Hawk and Taipan helicopters transported firefighters to fire grounds, and helped evacuate vulnerable people. Three Spartan aircraft assisted with evacuations.
On January 5 and 6 ADF flew in emergency food, fuel, water and medical supplies to 18 cut-off communities. On January 7 they prepared a staging area for around 100 international fire fighters around Omeo.
On January 7, further evacuations from Mallacoota took place, and satellite phones and food, medical supplies, water and fuel were delivered in some isolated locations, including Bemm River and Genoa.
Reconnaissance flights were conducted over fire affected areas on January 8. A medical team was deployed to remote towns such as Combienbar and Gipsy Point.
5400 litres of diesel and 800 litres of unleaded petrol were flown in to Mallacoota.
Equipment and Engineering personnel were provided to assist state government in reopening roads, removing debris and clearing fire breaks and fire trails. On January 9, ADF undertook route clearance north of Bairnsdale and the Great Alpine Road was reopened. Hay bales and fodder were moved into key locations. Air Force air traffic controllers assisted to help manage the large volume of air traffic at the Bairnsdale Airport.
From January 10, ADF undertook continued work in support of relief centres at Omeo, Swifts Creek, Bairnsdale, Orbost and Mallacoota. ADF also supported evacuations from the Victorian Alpine region.
Undertake internet research:
- Make a list of the different issues affecting the people of Mallacoota prior to the ADF assisting them?
- Make a list of the different tasks undertaken by The Australian Defence Force to assist the people of Mallacoota?
- Why do you think that The Australian Defence Force had to be called in to assist the people of Mallacoota? Was this a good decision? What are the costs and benefits of using the ADF in this way?
- What challenges did the ADF face in assisting the people of Mallacoota?
- Outline the effectiveness of The Australian Defence Force in responding to the bushfire crisis affecting Mallacootta.
Embedded below are social media posts from The Guardian, The Australian Defence Force, the Royal Australian Army and the Royal Australian Airforce.
- What is the purpose of The Australian Defence Force, Royal Australian Army and the Royal Australian Airforce posting updates about their activities? What are the benefits of these posts?
- Consider the following statement about media: "Media and media messages can influence beliefs, values, attitudes, behaviours and the democratic process." What messages are conveyed in the posts below? What values are communicated? How might these posts influence democratic processes?
Embedded below is a series of tweets by Brendan, a local resident of Mallacoota. As the emergency unfolded, he published updates on the progress of the fires and the experiences of him and his family, and later on his community. The tweets included below are just from the first few days of the disaster. You can also listen to an interview with Brendan by clicking here.
Unlike a formal newspaper article or a television news story, this is a very personal account, describing one man's individual experiences.
- Create a list of the impacts of the fire on this particular person.
- Create a list of impacts on the community of Mallacoota.
- Use the hashtags #Mallacoota, #Australianbushfires and/or #bushfires to search Twitter. Explore the perspectives of other residents during the emergency. Add to your lists above, and write a short description of the accounts of these individuals.
- Consider the language and the descriptions included in the accounts you have read. How do these differ from the language and descriptions in more formal pieces of writing or news such as newspaper articles or news reports?
- As a geographer, what are the advantages of reading personal accounts of a natural disaster such as the Australian Bushfires? What are the disadvantages?
- What steps could you take to verify the accounts of individuals on twitter or other forms of social media?
A range of spatial technologies have been used during and after the Australian Bushfires 2019-2020. Emergency Services have used apps to communicate with the public about the location of fires and the risk to the public. Members of the public have been able to refer to geospatial information about air quality and weather conditions, and following the fires, environmental groups have been able to use geospatial tools to communicate and coordinate locations of feeding and watering stations for wildlife.
MyFireWatch is a collaboration between Edith Cowan University and Landgate and tracks bushfires.
Current Bushfires is the Queensland Government - Rural Fire Service website.
Air Quality Index Visual Map
The Air Quality Index Visual Map uses Air Quality Monitoring stations to collect data about air quality and represent it spatially. Air Quality is categorised as Good, Moderate, Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups, Unhealthy, Very Unhealthy, Hazardous.
Bureau of Meteorology
The Australian Bureau of Meteorology website provides up to date information about weather conditions that may impact on bushfires, such as temperature and wind.
Water Our Wildlife CCWSAR Map
The Central Coast Wildlife Search and Rescue created a google map to share information about feeding and watering stations to help surviving wildlife. This enables volunteers to independently visit sites for restocking.
Water Our Wildlife CCWSAR Map
Some generic bushfire lesson plans and sequences:
GTA NSW - Geography Alive - Bushfire Hazards in Australia
Bushfire lesson plan - Australian Institute of Disaster Resilience
Bushfire Education - Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority
Preparing for an emergency - NSW Rural Fire Service
Bushfires and grassfires - CFA, Victoria
Learning about Bushfires - Victorian Curriculum and Assessment Authority
Geomorphology: the study of landforms, their origins, evolution, form and distribution.
The lithosphere is the outer shell of the earth, consisting of soil and geological formations. The earth is made up of different section: the core, the inner core, the outer core and the crust. Study of the lithosphere is primarily concerned with the crust.
The two sets of forces which shape the earth’s crust are tectonic forces (continental drift and plate movement at a smaller scale), and gradational forces (weathering, erosion, deposition and mass movement).
Landforms can be shaped in a number of ways:
Click to read Mystery island in the Southern Pacific brimming with life.
Slip, Slide Colide
Click to play Slip, Slide Collide
Volcanoes involve the process of molten rock from the mantle being forced up onto the earth’s surface, building continents.
When two plates come together, folding and faulting can occur which can cause earthquakes (see above). Earthquakes occur as a result of movement between sections of the earth’s crust. They commonly occur along fault lines and along plate boundaries. Sections of tectonic plates can be forced upwards exposing new sections.
When plates come together (or converge) underwater trenches and volcanoes can be formed.
Faulting - Block mountains
Block mountains are made when part of the crust is forced up between two cracks in a plate. These cracks are called faults.
Deputy Principal at a Sydney high school. Coordinating author of the new Geoactive book series.