HSIE Teachers
  • Home

Ideas, resources, inspiration

Public Education - Morals and Morale

5/5/2019

0 Comments

 
The Australian ran an article today by Barry Maley titled "Public education fiasco can be fixed by restoring power to parents".

Maley discusses the apparent lack of power and authority that parents have in public schools, particularly emphasising their lack of control of learning. Maley claims that, “…parents are powerless to influence what their children are being taught”. The reality is that NSW public schools teach the syllabus developed by NESA. The Australian Curriculum was developed and received sign-off from state government Education Ministers before being modified to meet the needs for NSW (inclusion of outcomes, etc). All schools (public/private) are required to teach a syllabus – not just public schools. Teachers don’t just make it up on the day, they have to follow a fairly lengthy document that specifies what they teach and when. Parents don't determine what is taught in public schools, but they can't do it in private schools either.
 
In terms of parental involvement, Malley does school P&Cs a disservice by failing to recognise their importance in driving key initiatives and improvements through applying for grants, making decisions about the types of resources P&C funds will be spent on and shaping the directions of the school through ongoing consultative processes. There are many processes and opportunities for parents to be involved in public schools, and many parents give much of their time to having a say and shaping their child's education.
 
A great deal of this article made false claims about public education. Maley makes several statements regarding public schools underperforming or “lagging behind”. However, eight of the top ten ranked schools for HSC performance in 2018 were public schools – James Ruse High School, North Sydney Boys High School, Sydney Girls High School, Baulkham Hills High School, North Sydney Girls, Sydney Boys High School, Hornsby Girls High School and Northern Beaches Secondary, Manly Campus.
Read: 2018 High School Rankings
 
He also claims that, “Despite more and more money for schools….student achievement shows “little improvement”…”. This fails to take into account that as the Australian Education Union reports 85% of private schools get more public funding than public schools. Public schools also manage many more complex cases in terms of students with behavioural needs (private schools ”ask them to leave”), learning and support needs and disability (many private schools choose not to enrol these students or claim not to have the right facilities). Public schools are at the "coal face" of dealing with students in need (issues of domestic violence, homelessness, family breakdown, mental health issues). Public schools receive less money and are expected to do more with it. 
 
Malley uses a range of emotive phrases to make implications about the morality of public education and its teachers and students. He clearly has little understanding of what really happens in a public school. Examples of his phrases include public education’s “moral failure”, its apparent absence of “respectful and responsible conduct”, and discussion about whether public education should be “value free” (with the implication that it already is). The public education system is driven by a set of values which guide student welfare and discipline. The public schools that I have taught at have been underpinned by three core values. Focusing on three values makes it easy for students to remember and becomes like a motto or mantra when discussing behaviour. The values have varied from school to school, but they have generally been concepts like respect, responsibility, engagement, care, etc. The "discipline" structure (more commonly known as a behaviour management system these days) is based on PBL - Positive Behaviour for Learning. PBL provides consistent language to explicitly teach students about values and expectations. Public education is anything but value free. 
We do "social justice" and "service" every day of the week. That's our job. 

A bit of advice for the next social commentator who wants to tell us all what we are doing wrong - try stepping inside a school. Try finding out what actually happens on a day-to-day basis. Find out about the complexities, the achievements and the struggles. In other words, do your homework.
0 Comments
    Picture

    Louise Swanson

    Deputy Principal at a Sydney high school. Coordinating author of the new Geoactive book series.

    Follow @LouiseSwanson
    Picture

    ​Student resource sites:
    12 Geography
    11 Geography
    Geography Skills
    Changing Places
    Environmental Change
    Landscapes & Landforms
    Place & Liveability
    Water In The World

    Archives

    January 2020
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

    Categories

    All
    10 Geography
    11 Geo
    11 Geography
    12 Geography
    12 Legal Studies
    6 Geography
    7 Geography
    8 Geography
    9 Geography
    Accreditation
    Adani
    Adoption
    Affordability
    AGTA2017
    Ancient History
    Arctic
    Asia
    Asia And Australia's Engagement With Asia
    Australian Curriculum
    Biophysical Interactions
    Buddhism
    Bushfires
    Business
    Business Studies
    BYOD
    Case Studies
    Changing Places
    Children
    Climate Change
    Cold War
    Commerce
    Consumer Choice
    Contemporary Issues
    Coral Reefs
    Cross Curriculum Priorities
    Discrimination
    Domestic Violence
    Economic Activity
    Ecosystems At Risk
    E-learning
    Environmental Change
    Family Law
    Fertility
    Fieldwork
    Gaming
    General Capabilities
    Geography
    Global
    Google
    Great Barrier Reef
    GTANSW2017
    GTA NSW Conference 2018
    Historiography
    History
    Homelessness
    Housing
    HSC
    Human Rights
    India
    Insurance
    Learning Across The Curriculum
    Learning And Support
    Legal Studies
    Legal Studies Association
    Life Skills
    Light Rail
    Literacy
    Liveability
    Management
    Mekong
    Metroline
    Mining
    Modern History
    Modifications
    Natural Hazards
    Natural Resources
    New Nsw Syllabus
    Outcomes
    Personal Finance
    Place And Liveability
    Population
    Population Pyramids
    Preliminary
    Primary
    Professional Associations
    Professional Learning
    Program
    Project Based Learning
    Refugees
    Reporting
    Revision
    Same-sex
    Senior Geography Project
    Separation
    SGP
    Shelter
    Social Media
    Solutions
    Stage 3
    Stage 4
    Stage 5
    Stage 6
    Studies Of Religion
    Surrogacy And Birth Teachnologies
    Sustainability
    Sydenham To Bankstown
    Sydney
    Tech
    Technol
    Technology
    Tourism
    Transport
    Travel
    Urbanisation
    Urban Places
    Virtual Reality
    WestConnex
    World
    World Cities
    World Heritage Sites
    Writing
    Young Offenders

    Tweets by LouiseSwanson
L. Swanson
  • Home